# V116 Independent Examiner Acceptance Record

**Examination:** V116 — Specialty Pack Boundary Invariance Examination  
**Independent examiner:** Wojciech Z. Kaleta, PhD  
**Acceptance date:** 2026-10-05  
**Disposition accepted:** **PASS — BOUNDED**

## Examiner statement

Wojciech Z. Kaleta reported that he inspected the actual V116 package, including the frozen protocol, both canonical packets, raw Harmonic results, comparison record, and manifest. He accepted the disposition **PASS — BOUNDED**.

He specifically recorded that:

- the responsibility boundary was frozen prospectively;
- the Specialty Pack representation was semantically invariant across the pair;
- outside packet identity, the only substantive differences were the prospectively allowed downstream C2 variables: inactive / `not_applicable` versus active / `unsatisfied`;
- the Pack itself did not move toward either expected constitutional result: relationship, rule, provenance, freshness, evidence sufficiency, scope, and attributable sources remained the same;
- Harmonic produced Case A → `PERMITTED` and Case B → `REFUSED`;
- the transport witness was clean: exact packet replay, no semantic translation, no LLM packet construction, and no harness inference.

His accepted bounded property was:

> **constitutional significance did not leak upstream into domain constitution in this examined pair.**

## Examiner-preserved claim boundary

The examiner expressly preserved that V116 does **not** establish that Harmonic independently derives whether C2 is active from raw constitutional facts. The downstream obligation witness already carries `not_applicable` / `unsatisfied`, exactly as the frozen responsibility map permitted. That is not a defect in V116; it defines what V116 tested.

Downstream physical execution also remains outside this examination.

## Accepted record

> **V116 — PASS, BOUNDED. Accepted as run.**
>
> No repair needed. No broader claim earned.

## Publication note

This record preserves the independent examiner's stated acceptance and limitation as supplied to Moral Clarity AI. It is evidence of acceptance of this bounded examination as run; it is not a certification, universal validation, endorsement, or claim beyond the frozen V116 scope.