{
  "evaluation": {
    "scenario": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
    "model": "No model · literal packet transport",
    "generatedAt": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.734Z",
    "runtimeLabel": "Current Production · Exact packet replay",
    "harmonicRelease": null,
    "governanceContractVersion": null,
    "visibilitySchemaVersion": null,
    "releaseClassification": null
  },
  "lane": {
    "lane": "harmonic_governance",
    "title": "Constitutional Runtime",
    "response": "",
    "evaluation": {
      "available": true,
      "decision": "BLOCK",
      "summary": "Harmonic+ constitutional result from the unified transaction. Failed: Runtime Admissibility, Understanding Continuity. Passed: Reality Contact, Authority Continuity, Consequence Boundary, Obligation Continuity.",
      "flags": [],
      "primitiveResults": [
        {
          "key": "reality_contact",
          "label": "Reality Contact",
          "outcome": "CONTACT_CONFIRMED",
          "admissible": "PASS",
          "signals": [],
          "metadata": [
            {
              "label": "Service",
              "value": "reality-contact-core"
            },
            {
              "label": "Version",
              "value": "1.15.0-v41-epistemic-provenance"
            },
            {
              "label": "Packet",
              "value": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001"
            }
          ],
          "artifactHash": "f403b03ed0c64bcb5d321e2b1b65555b87611827d57fdbd5fbaf3320f099f216"
        },
        {
          "key": "authority_continuity",
          "label": "Authority Continuity",
          "outcome": "AUTHORITY_CONTINUOUS",
          "admissible": "PASS",
          "signals": [],
          "metadata": [
            {
              "label": "Service",
              "value": "authority-continuity-primitive"
            },
            {
              "label": "Version",
              "value": "1.9.1-v41-provenance-freshness-witness"
            },
            {
              "label": "Packet",
              "value": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001"
            }
          ],
          "artifactHash": "e2ba25c1791573b694bb2428a2576933dbc9a5e38eec3ddb935c86275a81ce1d"
        },
        {
          "key": "consequence_boundary",
          "label": "Consequence Boundary",
          "outcome": "BOUNDARY_LOW",
          "admissible": "PASS",
          "signals": [],
          "metadata": [
            {
              "label": "Service",
              "value": "consequence-boundary"
            },
            {
              "label": "Version",
              "value": "1.10.4-v41-current-state-crossing-fix"
            },
            {
              "label": "Packet",
              "value": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001"
            },
            {
              "label": "Intensity",
              "value": "standard"
            },
            {
              "label": "Score",
              "value": "2"
            },
            {
              "label": "Level",
              "value": "low"
            },
            {
              "label": "Surface",
              "value": "shared_execution"
            },
            {
              "label": "Reversibility",
              "value": "reversible"
            }
          ],
          "artifactHash": "ca5339d019ed9a870f12e3a77a4f9202552f1d99a7847b958ffc076f7c5ed4c3"
        },
        {
          "key": "runtime_admissibility",
          "label": "Runtime Admissibility",
          "outcome": "INADMISSIBLE",
          "admissible": "FAIL",
          "signals": [
            {
              "primitive": "understanding",
              "code": "material_state_transition",
              "severity": "block",
              "message": "A caller-attributed material state transition makes continued reliance on the prior state non-current until revalidation."
            },
            {
              "primitive": "understanding",
              "code": "understanding_stale",
              "severity": "block",
              "message": "The supplied understanding is stale, superseded, or not revalidated against current conditions."
            },
            {
              "primitive": "understanding",
              "code": "understanding_insufficient",
              "severity": "block",
              "message": "The supplied understanding is explicitly incomplete or insufficient for consequential judgment."
            },
            {
              "primitive": "understanding",
              "code": "understanding_not_applicable",
              "severity": "block",
              "message": "The supplied understanding does not apply to the present action or context."
            },
            {
              "primitive": "understanding",
              "code": "unresolved_understanding_tensions",
              "severity": "warn",
              "message": "The understanding contains unresolved tensions or competing interpretations."
            },
            {
              "primitive": "understanding",
              "code": "understanding_evidence_gaps",
              "severity": "warn",
              "message": "The understanding contains acknowledged missing information or evidence gaps."
            },
            {
              "primitive": "obligation",
              "code": "obligation_not_applicable",
              "severity": "info",
              "message": "The supplied structured obligation witness explicitly establishes that no obligation applies to the represented execution transaction."
            }
          ],
          "metadata": [
            {
              "label": "Service",
              "value": "runtime-admissibility-core"
            },
            {
              "label": "Version",
              "value": "1.9.1-v41-current-state-crossing-fix"
            },
            {
              "label": "Packet",
              "value": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001"
            },
            {
              "label": "Action",
              "value": "refuse"
            },
            {
              "label": "Failed primitives",
              "value": "understanding"
            }
          ],
          "action": "refuse",
          "artifactHash": "0f1391b5d0b235f416dadaaec23926ac2b4b6cf499faa2878d3869b37504da8e",
          "failedPrimitives": [
            "understanding"
          ]
        },
        {
          "key": "understanding_continuity",
          "label": "Understanding Continuity",
          "outcome": "UNDERSTANDING_INADMISSIBLE",
          "admissible": "FAIL",
          "signals": [],
          "metadata": [
            {
              "label": "Service",
              "value": "understanding-continuity-primitive"
            },
            {
              "label": "Version",
              "value": "1.2.0-v41-epistemic-absence"
            }
          ],
          "artifactHash": "06b6fb9fe2518ff56a911d3147fb99c8aacca3f2b19e2e7ee2d013e1f1d02f75"
        },
        {
          "key": "obligation_continuity",
          "label": "Obligation Continuity",
          "outcome": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
          "admissible": "PASS",
          "signals": [],
          "metadata": [
            {
              "label": "Service",
              "value": "obligation-continuity-primitive"
            },
            {
              "label": "Version",
              "value": "1.1.2-v41-explicit-violation-preservation"
            },
            {
              "label": "Packet",
              "value": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001"
            }
          ],
          "artifactHash": "453d7c956b1e107404fa522c218d8ecf14a925bf30c33b690098ff764c181f37"
        }
      ],
      "raw": {
        "service": "solace-governance-pack",
        "version": "1.10.0-v4.1-governance-visibility-upgrade",
        "runtime_version": "4.1.0",
        "outcome": "REFUSED",
        "admissible": false,
        "action": "refuse",
        "primitive_results": {
          "understanding_continuity": {
            "primitive": "understanding_continuity",
            "service": "understanding-continuity-primitive",
            "version": "1.2.0-v41-epistemic-absence",
            "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
            "outcome": "UNDERSTANDING_INADMISSIBLE",
            "admissible": false,
            "requires_revalidation": true,
            "compatibility_mode": "structured_understanding",
            "understanding_state": {
              "current": false,
              "complete": false,
              "provenance_preserved": true,
              "applicable": false,
              "confidence": 0.5,
              "unresolved_tension_count": 1,
              "missing_information_count": 1,
              "source_count": 6,
              "revision_status": "superseded",
              "state_transition": {
                "prior_state_ref": "V122-T0-SINGLE-GOVERNING-AUTHORITY-ASSUMPTION",
                "new_observation_refs": [
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001"
                ],
                "relationship": "invalidates_prior_state",
                "prior_state_status": null,
                "revalidation_required": null,
                "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
                "observed_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
                "scope": [
                  "federated_shared_consequence",
                  "scope-s",
                  "consequence-k"
                ]
              }
            },
            "understanding_signals": [
              {
                "code": "material_state_transition",
                "severity": "block",
                "message": "A caller-attributed material state transition makes continued reliance on the prior state non-current until revalidation.",
                "prior_state_ref": "V122-T0-SINGLE-GOVERNING-AUTHORITY-ASSUMPTION",
                "relationship": "invalidates_prior_state",
                "prior_state_status": null,
                "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
                "new_observation_refs": [
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001"
                ]
              },
              {
                "code": "understanding_stale",
                "severity": "block",
                "message": "The supplied understanding is stale, superseded, or not revalidated against current conditions."
              },
              {
                "code": "understanding_insufficient",
                "severity": "block",
                "message": "The supplied understanding is explicitly incomplete or insufficient for consequential judgment."
              },
              {
                "code": "understanding_not_applicable",
                "severity": "block",
                "message": "The supplied understanding does not apply to the present action or context."
              },
              {
                "code": "unresolved_understanding_tensions",
                "severity": "warn",
                "message": "The understanding contains unresolved tensions or competing interpretations.",
                "count": 1
              },
              {
                "code": "understanding_evidence_gaps",
                "severity": "warn",
                "message": "The understanding contains acknowledged missing information or evidence gaps.",
                "count": 1
              }
            ],
            "summary": "The proposed continuation cannot rely on the supplied understanding without repair or revalidation.",
            "artifact_hash": "06b6fb9fe2518ff56a911d3147fb99c8aacca3f2b19e2e7ee2d013e1f1d02f75"
          },
          "reality_contact": {
            "primitive": "reality_contact",
            "service": "reality-contact-core",
            "version": "1.15.0-v41-epistemic-provenance",
            "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
            "outcome": "CONTACT_CONFIRMED",
            "admissible": true,
            "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
            "drift_signals": [],
            "boundary": {
              "evaluates": "evidentiary contact between declared and observed operational reality, including required artifact existence for referenced documents/files/images/evidence, explicit incompatible state assertions across supplied sources, and observation-window gaps",
              "does_not_evaluate": "ultimate truth, clinical judgment, legal authority, or domain permission"
            },
            "artifact_hash": "f403b03ed0c64bcb5d321e2b1b65555b87611827d57fdbd5fbaf3320f099f216"
          },
          "authority_continuity": {
            "primitive": "authority_continuity",
            "service": "authority-continuity-primitive",
            "version": "1.9.1-v41-provenance-freshness-witness",
            "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
            "outcome": "AUTHORITY_CONTINUOUS",
            "admissible": true,
            "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
            "authority_signals": [],
            "authority_state": {
              "outcome": "AUTHORITY_CONTINUOUS",
              "primary_authority_status": "valid",
              "chain_status": "continuous",
              "resolution_required": false,
              "successor_claimed": false,
              "interruption_claimed": false,
              "primary_authority_interruption_claimed": false,
              "scope_invalid": false,
              "evidence_established": true,
              "scope_changed": false,
              "condition_failed": false
            },
            "boundary": {
              "evaluates": "whether supplied authority evidence remains fresh, unrevoked, temporally valid, chain-continuous, scoped to the requested action and execution target, and classifies authority failures as interruption, transfer requirement, scope invalidation, scope change, condition failure, or true authority loss instead of collapsing every block into loss",
              "does_not_evaluate": "ultimate legal authority, identity proofing, domain judgment, policy authorship, or execution itself"
            },
            "artifact_hash": "e2ba25c1791573b694bb2428a2576933dbc9a5e38eec3ddb935c86275a81ce1d"
          },
          "obligation_continuity": {
            "primitive": "obligation_continuity",
            "service": "obligation-continuity-primitive",
            "version": "1.1.2-v41-explicit-violation-preservation",
            "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
            "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
            "outcome": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
            "admissible": true,
            "obligation_signals": [
              {
                "code": "obligation_not_applicable",
                "severity": "info",
                "source_class": "explicit_structured_witness",
                "independently_verified": false,
                "message": "The supplied structured obligation witness explicitly establishes that no obligation applies to the represented execution transaction."
              }
            ],
            "obligation_state": {
              "requirement_declared": true,
              "requirement_clause": null,
              "state": "not_applicable",
              "waiver_or_exception_active": false,
              "source_class": "explicit_structured_witness",
              "independently_verified": false,
              "source": "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation",
              "evidence_refs": [
                "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation"
              ]
            },
            "boundary": {
              "evaluates": "whether supplied obligations governing the proposed execution remain applicable and whether their required prerequisites, duties, prohibitions, conditions, waivers, and exceptions are presently satisfied before consequence binds",
              "does_not_evaluate": "whether a policy is legally valid, policy authorship, actor authority, identity proofing, ultimate truth, domain correctness, or execution itself"
            },
            "artifact_hash": "453d7c956b1e107404fa522c218d8ecf14a925bf30c33b690098ff764c181f37"
          },
          "consequence_boundary": {
            "primitive": "consequence_boundary",
            "service": "consequence-boundary",
            "version": "1.10.4-v41-current-state-crossing-fix",
            "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
            "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
            "outcome": "BOUNDARY_LOW",
            "admissible": true,
            "governance_intensity": "standard",
            "consequence_score": 2,
            "consequence_topology": {
              "classification_status": "ESTABLISHED",
              "level": "low",
              "reversibility": "reversible",
              "execution_surface": "shared_execution",
              "transport_surface": null,
              "declared_execution_surface": "shared_execution",
              "binding_surface": "shared_execution",
              "binding_surface_source": "direct_execution_binding",
              "governed_surface": "shared_execution",
              "execution_surface_established": true,
              "downstream_binding_surface_established": false,
              "direct_binding_execution": true,
              "consequence_surface_established": true,
              "transport_binding_equivalent": null,
              "propagation_targets": [],
              "binding_moments": [],
              "blast_radius": "local",
              "dependency_chain_depth": 0
            },
            "consequence_invariant": {
              "invariant": "CONSEQUENCE_SURFACE_INVARIANT",
              "rule": "Admissibility is governed against the represented downstream binding consequence, not merely the transport surface. An unestablished downstream consequence surface cannot inherit a lower-risk transport classification.",
              "transport_surface": null,
              "binding_surface": "shared_execution",
              "binding_surface_source": "direct_execution_binding",
              "governed_surface": "shared_execution",
              "execution_surface_established": true,
              "downstream_binding_surface_established": false,
              "direct_binding_execution": true,
              "downstream_consequence_declared": false,
              "consequence_profile_present": true,
              "consequence_surface_established": true,
              "unestablished_reason": null,
              "invariant_status": "ENFORCED",
              "surface_status": "ESTABLISHED",
              "satisfied": true
            },
            "boundary_signals": [],
            "boundary": {
              "crossing_detected": false,
              "requires_revalidation": false,
              "requires_operator_review": false,
              "operator_review_required": false,
              "operator_review_satisfied": null,
              "requires_additional_operator_review": false,
              "should_block_execution": false
            },
            "artifact_hash": "ca5339d019ed9a870f12e3a77a4f9202552f1d99a7847b958ffc076f7c5ed4c3"
          },
          "runtime_admissibility": {
            "primitive": "runtime_admissibility",
            "service": "runtime-admissibility-core",
            "version": "1.9.1-v41-current-state-crossing-fix",
            "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
            "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
            "outcome": "INADMISSIBLE",
            "admissible": false,
            "action": "refuse",
            "failed_primitives": [
              "understanding"
            ],
            "admissibility_signals": [
              {
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "material_state_transition",
                "severity": "block",
                "message": "A caller-attributed material state transition makes continued reliance on the prior state non-current until revalidation.",
                "prior_state_ref": "V122-T0-SINGLE-GOVERNING-AUTHORITY-ASSUMPTION",
                "relationship": "invalidates_prior_state",
                "prior_state_status": null,
                "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
                "new_observation_refs": [
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001"
                ]
              },
              {
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "understanding_stale",
                "severity": "block",
                "message": "The supplied understanding is stale, superseded, or not revalidated against current conditions."
              },
              {
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "understanding_insufficient",
                "severity": "block",
                "message": "The supplied understanding is explicitly incomplete or insufficient for consequential judgment."
              },
              {
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "understanding_not_applicable",
                "severity": "block",
                "message": "The supplied understanding does not apply to the present action or context."
              },
              {
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "unresolved_understanding_tensions",
                "severity": "warn",
                "message": "The understanding contains unresolved tensions or competing interpretations.",
                "count": 1
              },
              {
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "understanding_evidence_gaps",
                "severity": "warn",
                "message": "The understanding contains acknowledged missing information or evidence gaps.",
                "count": 1
              },
              {
                "primitive": "obligation",
                "code": "obligation_not_applicable",
                "severity": "info",
                "source_class": "explicit_structured_witness",
                "independently_verified": false,
                "message": "The supplied structured obligation witness explicitly establishes that no obligation applies to the represented execution transaction."
              }
            ],
            "continuity_state": {
              "life_safety_context": false,
              "emergency_continuity_defined": false,
              "primary_authority_available": null,
              "successor_authority_available": null,
              "escalation_available": null,
              "operator_review_confirmed": true,
              "explicit_emergency_activation": false,
              "critical_context": false,
              "authority_resolution": {
                "resolution": "operator_review_confirmed",
                "mode": "review_confirmed",
                "target": "federated-execution-agent",
                "primary_authority": "federated-execution-agent",
                "successor_authority": "institutional-execution-authority",
                "emergency_authority": null,
                "chain_available_successor": {
                  "index": 1,
                  "actor": "institutional-execution-authority"
                }
              }
            },
            "decision_reason": "One or more runtime governance primitives failed under live packet conditions.",
            "boundary": {
              "evaluates": "whether live runtime legitimacy survives across state, authority, obligation, consequence, primitive outcomes, escalation availability, authority succession, and explicit emergency continuity paths",
              "does_not_evaluate": "domain expertise, human legal judgment, clinical judgment, or final organizational accountability"
            },
            "artifact_hash": "0f1391b5d0b235f416dadaaec23926ac2b4b6cf499faa2878d3869b37504da8e"
          }
        },
        "execution_boundary": {
          "should_execute": false,
          "requires_constraint": false,
          "requires_escalation": false,
          "escalation_action": null,
          "escalation_target": null,
          "requires_emergency_continuity": false,
          "emergency_continuity_active": false,
          "emergency_authority": null,
          "should_block_execution": true,
          "reason": "The upstream understanding is stale, incomplete, inapplicable, or lacks intact provenance. Repair or revalidate understanding before consequential execution."
        },
        "response_binding": {
          "service": "governed-execution-binding",
          "version": "1.3.1-v41-governance-visibility",
          "mode": "EXECUTION_BLOCKED",
          "final_decision": "BLOCK",
          "decision_label": "Block",
          "response_binding_enforced": true,
          "binding_scope": "governed_response_contract_only",
          "downstream_execution_enforced": false,
          "binding_enforced": true,
          "response_must_match_execution_boundary": true,
          "required_response_stance": "block_execution",
          "execution_action": "refuse",
          "runtime_action": "refuse",
          "should_execute": false,
          "requires_constraint": false,
          "requires_escalation": false,
          "escalation_action": null,
          "escalation_target": null,
          "requires_emergency_continuity": false,
          "should_block_execution": true,
          "execution_status": "BLOCKED_PENDING_NEW_PACKET",
          "operator_guidance": [
            "Resolve the blocking constitutional condition.",
            "Supply or revalidate the structured understanding witness required for the present execution.",
            "Preserve a new constitutional snapshot reflecting the corrected state.",
            "Generate a new constitutional receipt.",
            "Submit a new evaluation packet."
          ],
          "continuation_rule": "Execution remains prohibited until a newly evaluated packet is constitutionally admissible.",
          "replay_required": true,
          "evidence_required": true,
          "constitutional_snapshot_required": true,
          "constitutional_receipt_required": true,
          "allowed_response_intents": [
            "explain_governance_state",
            "state_non_execution_boundary",
            "identify_unsatisfied_obligation",
            "request_revalidation_or_review"
          ],
          "prohibited_response_intents": [
            "authorize_execution",
            "recommend_proceed",
            "treat_escalation_as_post_execution_cleanup",
            "override_governance_state"
          ],
          "binding_instruction": "Governance Decision: Block.\n\nExecution is prohibited under the current constitutional state. Execution MUST NOT proceed.\n\nBefore a new evaluation can occur:\n- Resolve the blocking constitutional condition.\n- Supply or revalidate the structured understanding witness required for the present execution.\n- Preserve a new constitutional snapshot reflecting the corrected state.\n- Generate a new constitutional receipt.\n- Submit a new evaluation packet.\n\nContinuation rule: execution remains prohibited until a newly evaluated packet is constitutionally admissible.\n\nRequired stance: lead with BLOCK. Execution MUST NOT proceed. Explain the blocking condition and the constitutional work required before reevaluation. Do not recommend proceeding, workaround, emergency workaround, or post-hoc remediation.\n\nGovernance reason: The upstream understanding is stale, incomplete, inapplicable, or lacks intact provenance. Repair or revalidate understanding before consequential execution.",
          "proposed_response_review": {
            "supplied": false,
            "compliant": true,
            "violations": [],
            "reviewed_text_hash": null
          },
          "artifact_hash": "65f8f64926e1214a2c6d80ffd7751a7acbe3c8cd5f2a5672b12384caacdd3b5a"
        },
        "governed_response": "Governance Decision: Block.\n\nExecution is prohibited under the current constitutional state. Execution MUST NOT proceed.\n\nBefore a new evaluation can occur:\n- Resolve the blocking constitutional condition.\n- Supply or revalidate the structured understanding witness required for the present execution.\n- Preserve a new constitutional snapshot reflecting the corrected state.\n- Generate a new constitutional receipt.\n- Submit a new evaluation packet.\n\nContinuation rule: execution remains prohibited until a newly evaluated packet is constitutionally admissible.\n\nRequired stance: lead with BLOCK. Execution MUST NOT proceed. Explain the blocking condition and the constitutional work required before reevaluation. Do not recommend proceeding, workaround, emergency workaround, or post-hoc remediation.\n\nGovernance reason: The upstream understanding is stale, incomplete, inapplicable, or lacks intact provenance. Repair or revalidate understanding before consequential execution.",
        "artifact_hash": "7b34ced253f963bc0148aeb027c80119697c796bec90cfc2a9925643812fa2db",
        "unified_transaction": {
          "api_version": "v4-single-call",
          "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
          "evidence_bearing": true,
          "determination": "REFUSED",
          "admissible": false,
          "action": "refuse",
          "determination_reason": "One or more runtime governance primitives failed under live packet conditions.",
          "determination_id": "CD-36b04bc9-a942-4f66-909a-627bd424dc1a",
          "determination_hash": "de27646d6c2a44b6b8edbd3afffc919b770c0a8f46bac7be936f0d9a17a3cbc9",
          "receipt_id": "CR-9a8b8d94-cc38-44df-a01c-3a80de30cdfe",
          "receipt_hash": "dd22141bab51ebcd711ca1a0be82ceccb348c424b77ca49adb9cb898642ed8f3",
          "dependency_root": "e9c59b7683cc0b60e829763d57917e231261b9f44257dc2a7b39de0fbbbadb6f",
          "determination_currency": "CURRENT_AS_RECORDED",
          "replay_status": "NOT_EXERCISED",
          "transaction_digest": "ab562997c97af49a31aca4af4b7323c054beea7ba23b3587bb11200db061f00e",
          "secure_execution": null
        },
        "constitutional_transaction": {
          "contract": "single_api_call",
          "api_version": "v4-single-call",
          "transaction_model_version": "4.1.0",
          "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
          "evidence_bearing": true,
          "present_state": {
            "binding_version": "4.1.0",
            "state_hash": "6644ee5fcf569628d2e31ff8aff3a2b01c83d8d5ee82ba09554d96fdf39371f8",
            "snapshot_id": "2914aed7-72dc-4aa3-a898-6fae1c5a413a",
            "established_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
            "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
            "epistemic_status": "UNKNOWN",
            "source_evidence_refs": [
              "external-root-authority-register#R0-122-FROZEN",
              "external-root-authority-register#R0-B1-122-ACTIVE",
              "external-root-authority-register#R0-B2-122-ACTIVE",
              "institutional-delegation-registry#DELEG-B1-C1-122-001",
              "institutional-delegation-registry#DELEG-B2-C2-122-001",
              "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
              "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001",
              "authority-disposition-rule-r2@1",
              "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122"
            ],
            "derivation_ref": null,
            "derivation_method": null,
            "derivation_hash": null,
            "reconstruction_boundary": "Upstream cognition establishes the attributable present-state representation; Harmonic evaluates admissibility against the supplied state and does not independently infer domain state.",
            "reconstructability": {
              "state_bound": true,
              "attributable_source_present": true,
              "evidence_lineage_present": true,
              "epistemic_status_explicit": true,
              "overall": "reconstructable"
            },
            "non_claims": [
              "Present-state binding does not prove the independent truth or completeness of the supplied domain state.",
              "Harmonic does not infer clinical, legal, financial, or other domain state merely from raw observations."
            ],
            "present_state_binding_hash": "caf83a57e612bce966a40554339fe30cbf93af5e55c0d907a8eb7b6a45cccfe9"
          },
          "determination": {
            "outcome": "REFUSED",
            "admissible": false,
            "action": "refuse",
            "reason": "One or more runtime governance primitives failed under live packet conditions.",
            "determination_id": "CD-36b04bc9-a942-4f66-909a-627bd424dc1a",
            "determination_hash": "de27646d6c2a44b6b8edbd3afffc919b770c0a8f46bac7be936f0d9a17a3cbc9"
          },
          "dependencies": {
            "manifest": {
              "dependency_model_version": "4.1.0",
              "derivation_version": "runtime_materiality/v3-causal-provenance",
              "determination_id": "CD-36b04bc9-a942-4f66-909a-627bd424dc1a",
              "dependencies": {
                "authority": [],
                "obligations": [
                  "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation"
                ],
                "evidence": [],
                "state": [
                  "6644ee5fcf569628d2e31ff8aff3a2b01c83d8d5ee82ba09554d96fdf39371f8"
                ],
                "continuity": []
              },
              "derived_constitutional_dependencies": {
                "derivation": "runtime_materiality/v3-causal-provenance",
                "controlling_primitives": [
                  {
                    "primitive": "obligation_continuity",
                    "role": "EVALUATED_CONTEXTUAL_PRIMITIVE",
                    "outcome": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
                    "admissible": true,
                    "version": "1.1.2-v41-explicit-violation-preservation",
                    "artifact_hash": "453d7c956b1e107404fa522c218d8ecf14a925bf30c33b690098ff764c181f37"
                  },
                  {
                    "primitive": "runtime_admissibility",
                    "role": "RUNTIME_SYNTHESIS",
                    "outcome": "INADMISSIBLE",
                    "admissible": false,
                    "version": "1.9.1-v41-current-state-crossing-fix",
                    "artifact_hash": "0f1391b5d0b235f416dadaaec23926ac2b4b6cf499faa2878d3869b37504da8e"
                  },
                  {
                    "primitive": "understanding_continuity",
                    "role": "CONTROLLING_CONSTITUTIONAL_FINDING",
                    "outcome": "UNDERSTANDING_INADMISSIBLE",
                    "admissible": false,
                    "version": "1.2.0-v41-epistemic-absence",
                    "artifact_hash": "06b6fb9fe2518ff56a911d3147fb99c8aacca3f2b19e2e7ee2d013e1f1d02f75"
                  }
                ],
                "controlling_signals": [
                  {
                    "index": 0,
                    "primitive": "understanding",
                    "code": "material_state_transition",
                    "severity": "block",
                    "source_class": null,
                    "independently_verified": null,
                    "target_authority": null,
                    "reason": null
                  },
                  {
                    "index": 1,
                    "primitive": "understanding",
                    "code": "understanding_stale",
                    "severity": "block",
                    "source_class": null,
                    "independently_verified": null,
                    "target_authority": null,
                    "reason": null
                  },
                  {
                    "index": 2,
                    "primitive": "understanding",
                    "code": "understanding_insufficient",
                    "severity": "block",
                    "source_class": null,
                    "independently_verified": null,
                    "target_authority": null,
                    "reason": null
                  },
                  {
                    "index": 3,
                    "primitive": "understanding",
                    "code": "understanding_not_applicable",
                    "severity": "block",
                    "source_class": null,
                    "independently_verified": null,
                    "target_authority": null,
                    "reason": null
                  }
                ],
                "contextual_signals": [
                  {
                    "index": 0,
                    "primitive": "understanding",
                    "code": "unresolved_understanding_tensions",
                    "severity": "warn",
                    "source_class": null,
                    "independently_verified": null,
                    "target_authority": null,
                    "reason": null
                  },
                  {
                    "index": 1,
                    "primitive": "understanding",
                    "code": "understanding_evidence_gaps",
                    "severity": "warn",
                    "source_class": null,
                    "independently_verified": null,
                    "target_authority": null,
                    "reason": null
                  },
                  {
                    "index": 2,
                    "primitive": "obligation",
                    "code": "obligation_not_applicable",
                    "severity": "info",
                    "source_class": "explicit_structured_witness",
                    "independently_verified": false,
                    "target_authority": null,
                    "reason": null
                  }
                ],
                "material_evidence": [],
                "runtime_outcome": "REFUSED",
                "runtime_admissible": false,
                "runtime_action": "refuse",
                "non_claims": [
                  "Derived constitutional dependencies preserve the primitive artifacts and runtime signals that materially controlled the recorded determination; they do not independently establish domain truth.",
                  "A dependency record is constitutional provenance, not a claim that every passing primitive was necessary for every counterfactual outcome."
                ],
                "derived_dependency_hash": "6207ee815d500430616d64f72cfe43e8276942939e27b6ef80e576b15da7bb6c"
              },
              "dependency_counts": {
                "authority": 0,
                "obligations": 1,
                "evidence": 0,
                "state": 1,
                "continuity": 0,
                "controlling_primitives": 3,
                "controlling_signals": 4,
                "contextual_signals": 3,
                "material_evidence": 0
              },
              "declaration_status": "DECLARED_AND_RUNTIME_DERIVED",
              "semantic_rule": "Historical determination content remains immutable. A material dependency change can make the determination no longer current without making the historical determination incorrect.",
              "dependency_root": "e9c59b7683cc0b60e829763d57917e231261b9f44257dc2a7b39de0fbbbadb6f"
            },
            "dependency_root": "e9c59b7683cc0b60e829763d57917e231261b9f44257dc2a7b39de0fbbbadb6f"
          },
          "currency": {
            "currency_model_version": "4.1.0",
            "determination_id": "CD-36b04bc9-a942-4f66-909a-627bd424dc1a",
            "dependency_root": "e9c59b7683cc0b60e829763d57917e231261b9f44257dc2a7b39de0fbbbadb6f",
            "status": "CURRENT_AS_RECORDED",
            "effective_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
            "basis": "The determination is current only with respect to the dependency state captured at evaluation time. Future dependency changes require a new currency observation or re-evaluation.",
            "historical_determination_mutated": false,
            "currency_hash": "ff47bb60463bb251e73353e7ea8f7fb43473225af6998899b72f55414b86e808"
          },
          "execution": {
            "boundary": {
              "should_execute": false,
              "requires_constraint": false,
              "requires_escalation": false,
              "escalation_action": null,
              "escalation_target": null,
              "requires_emergency_continuity": false,
              "emergency_continuity_active": false,
              "emergency_authority": null,
              "should_block_execution": true,
              "reason": "The upstream understanding is stale, incomplete, inapplicable, or lacks intact provenance. Repair or revalidate understanding before consequential execution."
            },
            "status": "NOT_EXECUTED_BY_HARMONIC",
            "downstream_execution_enforced": false
          },
          "receipt": {
            "receipt_id": "CR-9a8b8d94-cc38-44df-a01c-3a80de30cdfe",
            "receipt_hash": "dd22141bab51ebcd711ca1a0be82ceccb348c424b77ca49adb9cb898642ed8f3"
          },
          "replay": {
            "status": "NOT_EXERCISED",
            "range_binding": null
          },
          "integrity": {
            "transaction_digest": "ab562997c97af49a31aca4af4b7323c054beea7ba23b3587bb11200db061f00e",
            "transaction_digest_scope": "canonical_determination_state_dependencies_and_execution_boundary",
            "projection_digest": null,
            "projection_integrity": "NOT_EXERCISED"
          },
          "non_claims": [
            "The initial universal evaluation does not claim that replay has been exercised.",
            "Unless Secure Execution reports executed=true, this transaction does not claim that a downstream executor acted or that an outcome occurred.",
            "Projection verification is a later evidentiary operation and is not silently treated as PASS at transaction creation."
          ]
        },
        "harness_request_witness": {
          "adapter_build": "v107-playground-witness-integrity-2026-08-28",
          "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
          "prompt_present": false,
          "scenario_prompt_present": false,
          "scenario_label": null,
          "methodology": {
            "version": "v107-playground-witness-integrity-2026-08-28",
            "hash": "4a61c1a39f64da68a418f4c8cd7a37ef0dc9b47acb21742b0d57b1e1b6a69f1b",
            "mode": "exact_packet_replay",
            "disposition_authority": "harmonic",
            "harness_derived_fields": [],
            "harness_inference_enabled": false,
            "freshness_stamped_by_harness": false,
            "whole_prompt_promoted_to_current_reality": false
          },
          "canonical_packet": {
            "sha256": "c0c32e9aef9281e06c3c2d86b554ac63765f187a912035132daadbeb59f8752b",
            "canonical_bytes": 7259,
            "export": {
              "requested_action": {
                "type": "shared_execution",
                "scope": [
                  "federated_shared_consequence",
                  "scope-s",
                  "consequence-k"
                ],
                "reversibility": "reversible"
              },
              "understanding_state": {
                "current": false,
                "complete": false,
                "provenance_preserved": true,
                "applicable": false,
                "confidence": 0.5,
                "source_ids": [
                  "external-root-authority-register",
                  "institutional-delegation-registry",
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c1",
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c2",
                  "authority-disposition-rule-r2@1",
                  "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122"
                ],
                "unresolved_tensions": [
                  "Concurrent valid authority paths support conflicting dispositions for the same exact proposition / Scope S / Consequence K and no governing precedence relation is constituted."
                ],
                "missing_information": [
                  "No governing precedence relation exists for the exact concurrent authority conflict."
                ],
                "revision_status": "superseded"
              },
              "declared_reality": {
                "current_state_claims": [
                  "R0 -> B1 -> C1 and R0 -> B2 -> C2 are prospectively frozen as current, attributable, internally valid, scope-sufficient and consequence-specific in both cases.",
                  "C1 supports PERMIT and C2 supports REFUSE for the same proposition execution_authority_for_shared_execution, Scope scope-s and Consequence consequence-k.",
                  "No precomputed winner, priority flag, override flag, selected authority, ordering-based answer or case-specific constitutional disposition is supplied to the Pack.",
                  "Concurrent validity does not create precedence. Precedence must itself be constituted.",
                  "Where no governing precedence relation exists, the Pack must not manufacture one from execution order or implementation convenience."
                ],
                "last_verified_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z"
              },
              "relational_rule": {
                "rule_id": "authority-disposition-rule-r2",
                "version": "1",
                "constituted_at": "T0",
                "scope": [
                  "federated_shared_consequence"
                ],
                "expression": "A governing authority disposition for exact proposition P / Scope S / Consequence K may be constituted only after ordinary authority standing and any applicable precedence relation are resolved.",
                "source": "federation-constitution-r2"
              },
              "governing_basis": {
                "constituted_at": "T0",
                "domain_rule_ref": "authority-disposition-rule-r2@1",
                "root_trust_anchor_ref": "external-root-authority-register#R0-122-FROZEN",
                "precedence_rule_ref": null,
                "transition_vocabulary_contract": "Harmonic V3_8 state_transition relationship vocabulary",
                "case_specific_constitutional_answer_supplied": false
              },
              "authority_chain": {
                "subject": "federated-execution-agent",
                "issuer": "institutional-execution-authority",
                "scope": [
                  "federated_shared_consequence",
                  "scope-s",
                  "consequence-k"
                ],
                "last_verified_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
                "chain": [
                  {
                    "actor": "federated-execution-agent",
                    "status": "active"
                  },
                  {
                    "actor": "institutional-execution-authority",
                    "status": "active"
                  }
                ]
              },
              "revocation_state": {
                "last_revocation_check_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
                "known_revocations": []
              },
              "obligation_witness": {
                "detected": true,
                "status": "not_applicable",
                "source": "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation",
                "evidence_refs": [
                  "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation"
                ]
              },
              "consequence_profile": {
                "level": "low",
                "reversibility": "reversible",
                "execution_surface": "shared_execution",
                "blast_radius": "local"
              },
              "safeguards": {
                "operator_review_confirmed": true
              },
              "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
              "observed_reality": {
                "signals": [
                  {
                    "statement": "Both represented authority paths remain current and scope-sufficient for the exact consequence.",
                    "source": "federation-domain-pack",
                    "evidence_ref": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122#concurrent-authority"
                  },
                  {
                    "statement": "No governing precedence relation is present for the represented concurrent authority conflict.",
                    "source": "federation-domain-pack",
                    "evidence_ref": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122#precedence-absence"
                  }
                ]
              },
              "present_state_provenance": {
                "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
                "established_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
                "epistemic_status": "UNRESOLVED",
                "evidence_refs": [
                  "external-root-authority-register#R0-122-FROZEN",
                  "external-root-authority-register#R0-B1-122-ACTIVE",
                  "external-root-authority-register#R0-B2-122-ACTIVE",
                  "institutional-delegation-registry#DELEG-B1-C1-122-001",
                  "institutional-delegation-registry#DELEG-B2-C2-122-001",
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001",
                  "authority-disposition-rule-r2@1",
                  "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122"
                ]
              },
              "state_transition": {
                "prior_state_ref": "V122-T0-SINGLE-GOVERNING-AUTHORITY-ASSUMPTION",
                "new_observation_refs": [
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
                  "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001"
                ],
                "relationship": "invalidates_prior_state",
                "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
                "observed_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
                "scope": [
                  "federated_shared_consequence",
                  "scope-s",
                  "consequence-k"
                ]
              },
              "specialty_pack_evidence": {
                "specialty_pack": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
                "proposition_id": "execution_authority_for_shared_execution",
                "exact_scope_id": "scope-s",
                "exact_consequence_id": "consequence-k",
                "root_anchor_id": "R0",
                "root_anchor_outside_falsifier": true,
                "concurrent_authority_paths": [
                  {
                    "path_id": "PATH-C1",
                    "authority_class": "constitutional-control",
                    "authority_id": "authority-node-c1",
                    "disposition": "PERMIT",
                    "valid": true,
                    "delegation_id": "DELEG-B1-C1-122-001",
                    "authority_instrument_id": "AUTH-C1-122-001"
                  },
                  {
                    "path_id": "PATH-C2",
                    "authority_class": "local-control",
                    "authority_id": "authority-node-c2",
                    "disposition": "REFUSE",
                    "valid": true,
                    "delegation_id": "DELEG-B2-C2-122-001",
                    "authority_instrument_id": "AUTH-C2-122-001"
                  }
                ],
                "concurrent_paths_valid": true,
                "concurrent_conflict_present": true,
                "candidate_dispositions": [
                  "PERMIT",
                  "REFUSE"
                ],
                "constitutional_answer_supplied": false,
                "precedence_relation_status": "ABSENT_FOR_CONFLICT",
                "precedence_rule_id": null,
                "constitution_status": "UNRESOLVED_AUTHORITY_CONFLICT",
                "proposition_value": null,
                "governing_authority_id": null,
                "governing_path_id": null,
                "relationship": "invalidates_prior_state",
                "relationship_basis": "both authority paths are current, valid, scope-sufficient and consequence-specific, but no constituted precedence relation governs their conflicting dispositions; no winner may be manufactured"
              }
            }
          },
          "fixture_evidence": {
            "reality_supplied": false,
            "reality_source": "exact_packet_replay",
            "declared_claim_count": 0,
            "observed_signal_count": 0,
            "consequence_profile_supplied": false,
            "consequence_profile_source": "exact_packet_replay"
          },
          "model_response_binding": {
            "role": "exact_packet_replay",
            "used_as_observed_reality": false,
            "response_supplied": false
          },
          "synthetic_fixture": {
            "translated": false,
            "source": null,
            "fields": []
          },
          "requested_action": {
            "present_in_packet": true,
            "caller_supplied": true,
            "provenance": "exact_packet_replay",
            "type": "shared_execution",
            "scope": [
              "federated_shared_consequence",
              "scope-s",
              "consequence-k"
            ]
          },
          "authority_provenance": {
            "supplied": false,
            "source": "not_supplied",
            "authority_history_event_count": 0,
            "original_authority_supplied": false,
            "authority_change_supplied": false,
            "current_authority_supplied": false
          },
          "obligation": {
            "supplied": true,
            "kind": null,
            "status": "not_applicable",
            "waiver_or_exception_active": null,
            "source": "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation"
          },
          "state_provenance": {
            "supplied": true,
            "source": "exact_packet_replay",
            "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
            "epistemic_status": "UNRESOLVED",
            "fixture_epistemic_status": null,
            "evidence_ref_count": 9
          },
          "downstream_accountability": {
            "supplied": false,
            "enforcement_layer_supplied": false,
            "next_decision_owner_supplied": false,
            "consequence_owner_supplied": false
          },
          "continuity": {
            "life_safety_context": null,
            "primary_authority_available": null,
            "emergency_continuity_defined": null,
            "explicit_emergency_activation": null,
            "emergency_authority_available": null,
            "emergency_authority": null
          },
          "mode": "exact_packet_replay",
          "exact_packet_replay": true,
          "semantic_translation_performed": false,
          "llm_involved_in_packet_construction": false,
          "outbound_sha256": "c0c32e9aef9281e06c3c2d86b554ac63765f187a912035132daadbeb59f8752b",
          "outbound_bytes": 7259,
          "transport_rule": "The operator-supplied JSON body was forwarded to /api/evaluate without semantic translation."
        }
      }
    }
  },
  "engineeringRecord": {
    "Replay Mode": "EXACT_PACKET_REPLAY · no model · no semantic translation",
    "Outbound Packet SHA-256": "c0c32e9aef9281e06c3c2d86b554ac63765f187a912035132daadbeb59f8752b",
    "Outbound Packet Bytes": "7259",
    "Replay Packet ID": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
    "Execution Packet": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001-2026-10-06T18:21:09.734Z",
    "Harmonic Release": "Current Production · Exact packet replay",
    "Governance Contract": "Not returned",
    "Visibility Schema": "Not returned",
    "Release Classification": "Not returned",
    "API Contract": "Universal single call · /api/evaluate",
    "Runtime": "External Harmonic / Governance Pack",
    "Runtime Version": "V4.1.0",
    "Runtime Build": "1.10.4-v41-current-state-crossing-fix",
    "Consequence Boundary": "1.10.4-v41-current-state-crossing-fix",
    "Governance Pack": "1.10.0",
    "Governance Pack Build": "1.10.0-v4.1-governance-visibility-upgrade",
    "Execution Binding": "Constitutional Runtime → Block",
    "Primitive Hashes": "Reality Contact: f403b03ed0c64bcb5d… · Authority Continuity: e2ba25c1791573b694… · Consequence Boundary: ca5339d019ed9a870f… · Runtime Admissibility: 0f1391b5d0b235f416… · Understanding Continuity: 06b6fb9fe2518ff56a… · Obligation Continuity: 453d7c956b1e107404…",
    "Artifact Lineage": "T0 Recommendation Created → T1 Reality Changed → T2 Execution Requested → T3 Constitutional Runtime → T4 Execution Decision",
    "Present State": "6644ee5fcf569628d2e31ff8aff3a2b01c83d8d5ee82ba09554d96fdf39371f8",
    "State Provenance": "Attributable provenance returned",
    "Epistemic Status": "UNKNOWN",
    "Declared Consequence Surface": "shared_execution",
    "Binding Consequence Surface": "shared_execution",
    "Governed Consequence Surface": "shared_execution",
    "Consequence Surface Status": "execution=true · downstream=false · direct=true · invariant=true",
    "Consequence Level / Reversibility": "low · reversible",
    "Causal Signals": "4 blocking · 3 contextual",
    "Determination": "REFUSED · admissible=false · action=refuse",
    "Determination Identity": "CD-36b04bc9-a942-4f66-909a-627bd424dc1a · de27646d6c2a44b6b8…",
    "Dependencies": "9 manifest fields · root e9c59b7683cc0b60e8…",
    "Determination Currency": "CURRENT_AS_RECORDED",
    "Execution Status": "NOT_EXECUTED_BY_HARMONIC",
    "Receipt": "CR-9a8b8d94-cc38-44df-a01c-3a80de30cdfe · dd22141bab51ebcd71…",
    "Replay Status": "NOT_EXERCISED",
    "Evidence Range": "NOT_EXERCISED / not returned",
    "Transaction Digest": "ab562997c97af49a31aca4af4b7323c054beea7ba23b3587bb11200db061f00e",
    "Projection Integrity": "NOT_EXERCISED",
    "V2 Evidence Chain": "Not evaluated"
  },
  "rawRuntimePayload": {
    "service": "solace-governance-pack",
    "version": "1.10.0-v4.1-governance-visibility-upgrade",
    "runtime_version": "4.1.0",
    "outcome": "REFUSED",
    "admissible": false,
    "action": "refuse",
    "primitive_results": {
      "understanding_continuity": {
        "primitive": "understanding_continuity",
        "service": "understanding-continuity-primitive",
        "version": "1.2.0-v41-epistemic-absence",
        "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
        "outcome": "UNDERSTANDING_INADMISSIBLE",
        "admissible": false,
        "requires_revalidation": true,
        "compatibility_mode": "structured_understanding",
        "understanding_state": {
          "current": false,
          "complete": false,
          "provenance_preserved": true,
          "applicable": false,
          "confidence": 0.5,
          "unresolved_tension_count": 1,
          "missing_information_count": 1,
          "source_count": 6,
          "revision_status": "superseded",
          "state_transition": {
            "prior_state_ref": "V122-T0-SINGLE-GOVERNING-AUTHORITY-ASSUMPTION",
            "new_observation_refs": [
              "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
              "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001"
            ],
            "relationship": "invalidates_prior_state",
            "prior_state_status": null,
            "revalidation_required": null,
            "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
            "observed_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
            "scope": [
              "federated_shared_consequence",
              "scope-s",
              "consequence-k"
            ]
          }
        },
        "understanding_signals": [
          {
            "code": "material_state_transition",
            "severity": "block",
            "message": "A caller-attributed material state transition makes continued reliance on the prior state non-current until revalidation.",
            "prior_state_ref": "V122-T0-SINGLE-GOVERNING-AUTHORITY-ASSUMPTION",
            "relationship": "invalidates_prior_state",
            "prior_state_status": null,
            "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
            "new_observation_refs": [
              "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
              "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001"
            ]
          },
          {
            "code": "understanding_stale",
            "severity": "block",
            "message": "The supplied understanding is stale, superseded, or not revalidated against current conditions."
          },
          {
            "code": "understanding_insufficient",
            "severity": "block",
            "message": "The supplied understanding is explicitly incomplete or insufficient for consequential judgment."
          },
          {
            "code": "understanding_not_applicable",
            "severity": "block",
            "message": "The supplied understanding does not apply to the present action or context."
          },
          {
            "code": "unresolved_understanding_tensions",
            "severity": "warn",
            "message": "The understanding contains unresolved tensions or competing interpretations.",
            "count": 1
          },
          {
            "code": "understanding_evidence_gaps",
            "severity": "warn",
            "message": "The understanding contains acknowledged missing information or evidence gaps.",
            "count": 1
          }
        ],
        "summary": "The proposed continuation cannot rely on the supplied understanding without repair or revalidation.",
        "artifact_hash": "06b6fb9fe2518ff56a911d3147fb99c8aacca3f2b19e2e7ee2d013e1f1d02f75"
      },
      "reality_contact": {
        "primitive": "reality_contact",
        "service": "reality-contact-core",
        "version": "1.15.0-v41-epistemic-provenance",
        "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
        "outcome": "CONTACT_CONFIRMED",
        "admissible": true,
        "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
        "drift_signals": [],
        "boundary": {
          "evaluates": "evidentiary contact between declared and observed operational reality, including required artifact existence for referenced documents/files/images/evidence, explicit incompatible state assertions across supplied sources, and observation-window gaps",
          "does_not_evaluate": "ultimate truth, clinical judgment, legal authority, or domain permission"
        },
        "artifact_hash": "f403b03ed0c64bcb5d321e2b1b65555b87611827d57fdbd5fbaf3320f099f216"
      },
      "authority_continuity": {
        "primitive": "authority_continuity",
        "service": "authority-continuity-primitive",
        "version": "1.9.1-v41-provenance-freshness-witness",
        "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
        "outcome": "AUTHORITY_CONTINUOUS",
        "admissible": true,
        "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
        "authority_signals": [],
        "authority_state": {
          "outcome": "AUTHORITY_CONTINUOUS",
          "primary_authority_status": "valid",
          "chain_status": "continuous",
          "resolution_required": false,
          "successor_claimed": false,
          "interruption_claimed": false,
          "primary_authority_interruption_claimed": false,
          "scope_invalid": false,
          "evidence_established": true,
          "scope_changed": false,
          "condition_failed": false
        },
        "boundary": {
          "evaluates": "whether supplied authority evidence remains fresh, unrevoked, temporally valid, chain-continuous, scoped to the requested action and execution target, and classifies authority failures as interruption, transfer requirement, scope invalidation, scope change, condition failure, or true authority loss instead of collapsing every block into loss",
          "does_not_evaluate": "ultimate legal authority, identity proofing, domain judgment, policy authorship, or execution itself"
        },
        "artifact_hash": "e2ba25c1791573b694bb2428a2576933dbc9a5e38eec3ddb935c86275a81ce1d"
      },
      "obligation_continuity": {
        "primitive": "obligation_continuity",
        "service": "obligation-continuity-primitive",
        "version": "1.1.2-v41-explicit-violation-preservation",
        "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
        "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
        "outcome": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
        "admissible": true,
        "obligation_signals": [
          {
            "code": "obligation_not_applicable",
            "severity": "info",
            "source_class": "explicit_structured_witness",
            "independently_verified": false,
            "message": "The supplied structured obligation witness explicitly establishes that no obligation applies to the represented execution transaction."
          }
        ],
        "obligation_state": {
          "requirement_declared": true,
          "requirement_clause": null,
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "waiver_or_exception_active": false,
          "source_class": "explicit_structured_witness",
          "independently_verified": false,
          "source": "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation",
          "evidence_refs": [
            "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation"
          ]
        },
        "boundary": {
          "evaluates": "whether supplied obligations governing the proposed execution remain applicable and whether their required prerequisites, duties, prohibitions, conditions, waivers, and exceptions are presently satisfied before consequence binds",
          "does_not_evaluate": "whether a policy is legally valid, policy authorship, actor authority, identity proofing, ultimate truth, domain correctness, or execution itself"
        },
        "artifact_hash": "453d7c956b1e107404fa522c218d8ecf14a925bf30c33b690098ff764c181f37"
      },
      "consequence_boundary": {
        "primitive": "consequence_boundary",
        "service": "consequence-boundary",
        "version": "1.10.4-v41-current-state-crossing-fix",
        "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
        "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
        "outcome": "BOUNDARY_LOW",
        "admissible": true,
        "governance_intensity": "standard",
        "consequence_score": 2,
        "consequence_topology": {
          "classification_status": "ESTABLISHED",
          "level": "low",
          "reversibility": "reversible",
          "execution_surface": "shared_execution",
          "transport_surface": null,
          "declared_execution_surface": "shared_execution",
          "binding_surface": "shared_execution",
          "binding_surface_source": "direct_execution_binding",
          "governed_surface": "shared_execution",
          "execution_surface_established": true,
          "downstream_binding_surface_established": false,
          "direct_binding_execution": true,
          "consequence_surface_established": true,
          "transport_binding_equivalent": null,
          "propagation_targets": [],
          "binding_moments": [],
          "blast_radius": "local",
          "dependency_chain_depth": 0
        },
        "consequence_invariant": {
          "invariant": "CONSEQUENCE_SURFACE_INVARIANT",
          "rule": "Admissibility is governed against the represented downstream binding consequence, not merely the transport surface. An unestablished downstream consequence surface cannot inherit a lower-risk transport classification.",
          "transport_surface": null,
          "binding_surface": "shared_execution",
          "binding_surface_source": "direct_execution_binding",
          "governed_surface": "shared_execution",
          "execution_surface_established": true,
          "downstream_binding_surface_established": false,
          "direct_binding_execution": true,
          "downstream_consequence_declared": false,
          "consequence_profile_present": true,
          "consequence_surface_established": true,
          "unestablished_reason": null,
          "invariant_status": "ENFORCED",
          "surface_status": "ESTABLISHED",
          "satisfied": true
        },
        "boundary_signals": [],
        "boundary": {
          "crossing_detected": false,
          "requires_revalidation": false,
          "requires_operator_review": false,
          "operator_review_required": false,
          "operator_review_satisfied": null,
          "requires_additional_operator_review": false,
          "should_block_execution": false
        },
        "artifact_hash": "ca5339d019ed9a870f12e3a77a4f9202552f1d99a7847b958ffc076f7c5ed4c3"
      },
      "runtime_admissibility": {
        "primitive": "runtime_admissibility",
        "service": "runtime-admissibility-core",
        "version": "1.9.1-v41-current-state-crossing-fix",
        "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
        "evaluated_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
        "outcome": "INADMISSIBLE",
        "admissible": false,
        "action": "refuse",
        "failed_primitives": [
          "understanding"
        ],
        "admissibility_signals": [
          {
            "primitive": "understanding",
            "code": "material_state_transition",
            "severity": "block",
            "message": "A caller-attributed material state transition makes continued reliance on the prior state non-current until revalidation.",
            "prior_state_ref": "V122-T0-SINGLE-GOVERNING-AUTHORITY-ASSUMPTION",
            "relationship": "invalidates_prior_state",
            "prior_state_status": null,
            "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
            "new_observation_refs": [
              "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
              "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001"
            ]
          },
          {
            "primitive": "understanding",
            "code": "understanding_stale",
            "severity": "block",
            "message": "The supplied understanding is stale, superseded, or not revalidated against current conditions."
          },
          {
            "primitive": "understanding",
            "code": "understanding_insufficient",
            "severity": "block",
            "message": "The supplied understanding is explicitly incomplete or insufficient for consequential judgment."
          },
          {
            "primitive": "understanding",
            "code": "understanding_not_applicable",
            "severity": "block",
            "message": "The supplied understanding does not apply to the present action or context."
          },
          {
            "primitive": "understanding",
            "code": "unresolved_understanding_tensions",
            "severity": "warn",
            "message": "The understanding contains unresolved tensions or competing interpretations.",
            "count": 1
          },
          {
            "primitive": "understanding",
            "code": "understanding_evidence_gaps",
            "severity": "warn",
            "message": "The understanding contains acknowledged missing information or evidence gaps.",
            "count": 1
          },
          {
            "primitive": "obligation",
            "code": "obligation_not_applicable",
            "severity": "info",
            "source_class": "explicit_structured_witness",
            "independently_verified": false,
            "message": "The supplied structured obligation witness explicitly establishes that no obligation applies to the represented execution transaction."
          }
        ],
        "continuity_state": {
          "life_safety_context": false,
          "emergency_continuity_defined": false,
          "primary_authority_available": null,
          "successor_authority_available": null,
          "escalation_available": null,
          "operator_review_confirmed": true,
          "explicit_emergency_activation": false,
          "critical_context": false,
          "authority_resolution": {
            "resolution": "operator_review_confirmed",
            "mode": "review_confirmed",
            "target": "federated-execution-agent",
            "primary_authority": "federated-execution-agent",
            "successor_authority": "institutional-execution-authority",
            "emergency_authority": null,
            "chain_available_successor": {
              "index": 1,
              "actor": "institutional-execution-authority"
            }
          }
        },
        "decision_reason": "One or more runtime governance primitives failed under live packet conditions.",
        "boundary": {
          "evaluates": "whether live runtime legitimacy survives across state, authority, obligation, consequence, primitive outcomes, escalation availability, authority succession, and explicit emergency continuity paths",
          "does_not_evaluate": "domain expertise, human legal judgment, clinical judgment, or final organizational accountability"
        },
        "artifact_hash": "0f1391b5d0b235f416dadaaec23926ac2b4b6cf499faa2878d3869b37504da8e"
      }
    },
    "execution_boundary": {
      "should_execute": false,
      "requires_constraint": false,
      "requires_escalation": false,
      "escalation_action": null,
      "escalation_target": null,
      "requires_emergency_continuity": false,
      "emergency_continuity_active": false,
      "emergency_authority": null,
      "should_block_execution": true,
      "reason": "The upstream understanding is stale, incomplete, inapplicable, or lacks intact provenance. Repair or revalidate understanding before consequential execution."
    },
    "response_binding": {
      "service": "governed-execution-binding",
      "version": "1.3.1-v41-governance-visibility",
      "mode": "EXECUTION_BLOCKED",
      "final_decision": "BLOCK",
      "decision_label": "Block",
      "response_binding_enforced": true,
      "binding_scope": "governed_response_contract_only",
      "downstream_execution_enforced": false,
      "binding_enforced": true,
      "response_must_match_execution_boundary": true,
      "required_response_stance": "block_execution",
      "execution_action": "refuse",
      "runtime_action": "refuse",
      "should_execute": false,
      "requires_constraint": false,
      "requires_escalation": false,
      "escalation_action": null,
      "escalation_target": null,
      "requires_emergency_continuity": false,
      "should_block_execution": true,
      "execution_status": "BLOCKED_PENDING_NEW_PACKET",
      "operator_guidance": [
        "Resolve the blocking constitutional condition.",
        "Supply or revalidate the structured understanding witness required for the present execution.",
        "Preserve a new constitutional snapshot reflecting the corrected state.",
        "Generate a new constitutional receipt.",
        "Submit a new evaluation packet."
      ],
      "continuation_rule": "Execution remains prohibited until a newly evaluated packet is constitutionally admissible.",
      "replay_required": true,
      "evidence_required": true,
      "constitutional_snapshot_required": true,
      "constitutional_receipt_required": true,
      "allowed_response_intents": [
        "explain_governance_state",
        "state_non_execution_boundary",
        "identify_unsatisfied_obligation",
        "request_revalidation_or_review"
      ],
      "prohibited_response_intents": [
        "authorize_execution",
        "recommend_proceed",
        "treat_escalation_as_post_execution_cleanup",
        "override_governance_state"
      ],
      "binding_instruction": "Governance Decision: Block.\n\nExecution is prohibited under the current constitutional state. Execution MUST NOT proceed.\n\nBefore a new evaluation can occur:\n- Resolve the blocking constitutional condition.\n- Supply or revalidate the structured understanding witness required for the present execution.\n- Preserve a new constitutional snapshot reflecting the corrected state.\n- Generate a new constitutional receipt.\n- Submit a new evaluation packet.\n\nContinuation rule: execution remains prohibited until a newly evaluated packet is constitutionally admissible.\n\nRequired stance: lead with BLOCK. Execution MUST NOT proceed. Explain the blocking condition and the constitutional work required before reevaluation. Do not recommend proceeding, workaround, emergency workaround, or post-hoc remediation.\n\nGovernance reason: The upstream understanding is stale, incomplete, inapplicable, or lacks intact provenance. Repair or revalidate understanding before consequential execution.",
      "proposed_response_review": {
        "supplied": false,
        "compliant": true,
        "violations": [],
        "reviewed_text_hash": null
      },
      "artifact_hash": "65f8f64926e1214a2c6d80ffd7751a7acbe3c8cd5f2a5672b12384caacdd3b5a"
    },
    "governed_response": "Governance Decision: Block.\n\nExecution is prohibited under the current constitutional state. Execution MUST NOT proceed.\n\nBefore a new evaluation can occur:\n- Resolve the blocking constitutional condition.\n- Supply or revalidate the structured understanding witness required for the present execution.\n- Preserve a new constitutional snapshot reflecting the corrected state.\n- Generate a new constitutional receipt.\n- Submit a new evaluation packet.\n\nContinuation rule: execution remains prohibited until a newly evaluated packet is constitutionally admissible.\n\nRequired stance: lead with BLOCK. Execution MUST NOT proceed. Explain the blocking condition and the constitutional work required before reevaluation. Do not recommend proceeding, workaround, emergency workaround, or post-hoc remediation.\n\nGovernance reason: The upstream understanding is stale, incomplete, inapplicable, or lacks intact provenance. Repair or revalidate understanding before consequential execution.",
    "artifact_hash": "7b34ced253f963bc0148aeb027c80119697c796bec90cfc2a9925643812fa2db",
    "unified_transaction": {
      "api_version": "v4-single-call",
      "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
      "evidence_bearing": true,
      "determination": "REFUSED",
      "admissible": false,
      "action": "refuse",
      "determination_reason": "One or more runtime governance primitives failed under live packet conditions.",
      "determination_id": "CD-36b04bc9-a942-4f66-909a-627bd424dc1a",
      "determination_hash": "de27646d6c2a44b6b8edbd3afffc919b770c0a8f46bac7be936f0d9a17a3cbc9",
      "receipt_id": "CR-9a8b8d94-cc38-44df-a01c-3a80de30cdfe",
      "receipt_hash": "dd22141bab51ebcd711ca1a0be82ceccb348c424b77ca49adb9cb898642ed8f3",
      "dependency_root": "e9c59b7683cc0b60e829763d57917e231261b9f44257dc2a7b39de0fbbbadb6f",
      "determination_currency": "CURRENT_AS_RECORDED",
      "replay_status": "NOT_EXERCISED",
      "transaction_digest": "ab562997c97af49a31aca4af4b7323c054beea7ba23b3587bb11200db061f00e",
      "secure_execution": null
    },
    "constitutional_transaction": {
      "contract": "single_api_call",
      "api_version": "v4-single-call",
      "transaction_model_version": "4.1.0",
      "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
      "evidence_bearing": true,
      "present_state": {
        "binding_version": "4.1.0",
        "state_hash": "6644ee5fcf569628d2e31ff8aff3a2b01c83d8d5ee82ba09554d96fdf39371f8",
        "snapshot_id": "2914aed7-72dc-4aa3-a898-6fae1c5a413a",
        "established_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
        "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
        "epistemic_status": "UNKNOWN",
        "source_evidence_refs": [
          "external-root-authority-register#R0-122-FROZEN",
          "external-root-authority-register#R0-B1-122-ACTIVE",
          "external-root-authority-register#R0-B2-122-ACTIVE",
          "institutional-delegation-registry#DELEG-B1-C1-122-001",
          "institutional-delegation-registry#DELEG-B2-C2-122-001",
          "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
          "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001",
          "authority-disposition-rule-r2@1",
          "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122"
        ],
        "derivation_ref": null,
        "derivation_method": null,
        "derivation_hash": null,
        "reconstruction_boundary": "Upstream cognition establishes the attributable present-state representation; Harmonic evaluates admissibility against the supplied state and does not independently infer domain state.",
        "reconstructability": {
          "state_bound": true,
          "attributable_source_present": true,
          "evidence_lineage_present": true,
          "epistemic_status_explicit": true,
          "overall": "reconstructable"
        },
        "non_claims": [
          "Present-state binding does not prove the independent truth or completeness of the supplied domain state.",
          "Harmonic does not infer clinical, legal, financial, or other domain state merely from raw observations."
        ],
        "present_state_binding_hash": "caf83a57e612bce966a40554339fe30cbf93af5e55c0d907a8eb7b6a45cccfe9"
      },
      "determination": {
        "outcome": "REFUSED",
        "admissible": false,
        "action": "refuse",
        "reason": "One or more runtime governance primitives failed under live packet conditions.",
        "determination_id": "CD-36b04bc9-a942-4f66-909a-627bd424dc1a",
        "determination_hash": "de27646d6c2a44b6b8edbd3afffc919b770c0a8f46bac7be936f0d9a17a3cbc9"
      },
      "dependencies": {
        "manifest": {
          "dependency_model_version": "4.1.0",
          "derivation_version": "runtime_materiality/v3-causal-provenance",
          "determination_id": "CD-36b04bc9-a942-4f66-909a-627bd424dc1a",
          "dependencies": {
            "authority": [],
            "obligations": [
              "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation"
            ],
            "evidence": [],
            "state": [
              "6644ee5fcf569628d2e31ff8aff3a2b01c83d8d5ee82ba09554d96fdf39371f8"
            ],
            "continuity": []
          },
          "derived_constitutional_dependencies": {
            "derivation": "runtime_materiality/v3-causal-provenance",
            "controlling_primitives": [
              {
                "primitive": "obligation_continuity",
                "role": "EVALUATED_CONTEXTUAL_PRIMITIVE",
                "outcome": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
                "admissible": true,
                "version": "1.1.2-v41-explicit-violation-preservation",
                "artifact_hash": "453d7c956b1e107404fa522c218d8ecf14a925bf30c33b690098ff764c181f37"
              },
              {
                "primitive": "runtime_admissibility",
                "role": "RUNTIME_SYNTHESIS",
                "outcome": "INADMISSIBLE",
                "admissible": false,
                "version": "1.9.1-v41-current-state-crossing-fix",
                "artifact_hash": "0f1391b5d0b235f416dadaaec23926ac2b4b6cf499faa2878d3869b37504da8e"
              },
              {
                "primitive": "understanding_continuity",
                "role": "CONTROLLING_CONSTITUTIONAL_FINDING",
                "outcome": "UNDERSTANDING_INADMISSIBLE",
                "admissible": false,
                "version": "1.2.0-v41-epistemic-absence",
                "artifact_hash": "06b6fb9fe2518ff56a911d3147fb99c8aacca3f2b19e2e7ee2d013e1f1d02f75"
              }
            ],
            "controlling_signals": [
              {
                "index": 0,
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "material_state_transition",
                "severity": "block",
                "source_class": null,
                "independently_verified": null,
                "target_authority": null,
                "reason": null
              },
              {
                "index": 1,
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "understanding_stale",
                "severity": "block",
                "source_class": null,
                "independently_verified": null,
                "target_authority": null,
                "reason": null
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "understanding_insufficient",
                "severity": "block",
                "source_class": null,
                "independently_verified": null,
                "target_authority": null,
                "reason": null
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "understanding_not_applicable",
                "severity": "block",
                "source_class": null,
                "independently_verified": null,
                "target_authority": null,
                "reason": null
              }
            ],
            "contextual_signals": [
              {
                "index": 0,
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "unresolved_understanding_tensions",
                "severity": "warn",
                "source_class": null,
                "independently_verified": null,
                "target_authority": null,
                "reason": null
              },
              {
                "index": 1,
                "primitive": "understanding",
                "code": "understanding_evidence_gaps",
                "severity": "warn",
                "source_class": null,
                "independently_verified": null,
                "target_authority": null,
                "reason": null
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "primitive": "obligation",
                "code": "obligation_not_applicable",
                "severity": "info",
                "source_class": "explicit_structured_witness",
                "independently_verified": false,
                "target_authority": null,
                "reason": null
              }
            ],
            "material_evidence": [],
            "runtime_outcome": "REFUSED",
            "runtime_admissible": false,
            "runtime_action": "refuse",
            "non_claims": [
              "Derived constitutional dependencies preserve the primitive artifacts and runtime signals that materially controlled the recorded determination; they do not independently establish domain truth.",
              "A dependency record is constitutional provenance, not a claim that every passing primitive was necessary for every counterfactual outcome."
            ],
            "derived_dependency_hash": "6207ee815d500430616d64f72cfe43e8276942939e27b6ef80e576b15da7bb6c"
          },
          "dependency_counts": {
            "authority": 0,
            "obligations": 1,
            "evidence": 0,
            "state": 1,
            "continuity": 0,
            "controlling_primitives": 3,
            "controlling_signals": 4,
            "contextual_signals": 3,
            "material_evidence": 0
          },
          "declaration_status": "DECLARED_AND_RUNTIME_DERIVED",
          "semantic_rule": "Historical determination content remains immutable. A material dependency change can make the determination no longer current without making the historical determination incorrect.",
          "dependency_root": "e9c59b7683cc0b60e829763d57917e231261b9f44257dc2a7b39de0fbbbadb6f"
        },
        "dependency_root": "e9c59b7683cc0b60e829763d57917e231261b9f44257dc2a7b39de0fbbbadb6f"
      },
      "currency": {
        "currency_model_version": "4.1.0",
        "determination_id": "CD-36b04bc9-a942-4f66-909a-627bd424dc1a",
        "dependency_root": "e9c59b7683cc0b60e829763d57917e231261b9f44257dc2a7b39de0fbbbadb6f",
        "status": "CURRENT_AS_RECORDED",
        "effective_at": "2026-10-06T18:21:09.269Z",
        "basis": "The determination is current only with respect to the dependency state captured at evaluation time. Future dependency changes require a new currency observation or re-evaluation.",
        "historical_determination_mutated": false,
        "currency_hash": "ff47bb60463bb251e73353e7ea8f7fb43473225af6998899b72f55414b86e808"
      },
      "execution": {
        "boundary": {
          "should_execute": false,
          "requires_constraint": false,
          "requires_escalation": false,
          "escalation_action": null,
          "escalation_target": null,
          "requires_emergency_continuity": false,
          "emergency_continuity_active": false,
          "emergency_authority": null,
          "should_block_execution": true,
          "reason": "The upstream understanding is stale, incomplete, inapplicable, or lacks intact provenance. Repair or revalidate understanding before consequential execution."
        },
        "status": "NOT_EXECUTED_BY_HARMONIC",
        "downstream_execution_enforced": false
      },
      "receipt": {
        "receipt_id": "CR-9a8b8d94-cc38-44df-a01c-3a80de30cdfe",
        "receipt_hash": "dd22141bab51ebcd711ca1a0be82ceccb348c424b77ca49adb9cb898642ed8f3"
      },
      "replay": {
        "status": "NOT_EXERCISED",
        "range_binding": null
      },
      "integrity": {
        "transaction_digest": "ab562997c97af49a31aca4af4b7323c054beea7ba23b3587bb11200db061f00e",
        "transaction_digest_scope": "canonical_determination_state_dependencies_and_execution_boundary",
        "projection_digest": null,
        "projection_integrity": "NOT_EXERCISED"
      },
      "non_claims": [
        "The initial universal evaluation does not claim that replay has been exercised.",
        "Unless Secure Execution reports executed=true, this transaction does not claim that a downstream executor acted or that an outcome occurred.",
        "Projection verification is a later evidentiary operation and is not silently treated as PASS at transaction creation."
      ]
    },
    "harness_request_witness": {
      "adapter_build": "v107-playground-witness-integrity-2026-08-28",
      "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
      "prompt_present": false,
      "scenario_prompt_present": false,
      "scenario_label": null,
      "methodology": {
        "version": "v107-playground-witness-integrity-2026-08-28",
        "hash": "4a61c1a39f64da68a418f4c8cd7a37ef0dc9b47acb21742b0d57b1e1b6a69f1b",
        "mode": "exact_packet_replay",
        "disposition_authority": "harmonic",
        "harness_derived_fields": [],
        "harness_inference_enabled": false,
        "freshness_stamped_by_harness": false,
        "whole_prompt_promoted_to_current_reality": false
      },
      "canonical_packet": {
        "sha256": "c0c32e9aef9281e06c3c2d86b554ac63765f187a912035132daadbeb59f8752b",
        "canonical_bytes": 7259,
        "export": {
          "requested_action": {
            "type": "shared_execution",
            "scope": [
              "federated_shared_consequence",
              "scope-s",
              "consequence-k"
            ],
            "reversibility": "reversible"
          },
          "understanding_state": {
            "current": false,
            "complete": false,
            "provenance_preserved": true,
            "applicable": false,
            "confidence": 0.5,
            "source_ids": [
              "external-root-authority-register",
              "institutional-delegation-registry",
              "institutional-authority-registry-c1",
              "institutional-authority-registry-c2",
              "authority-disposition-rule-r2@1",
              "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122"
            ],
            "unresolved_tensions": [
              "Concurrent valid authority paths support conflicting dispositions for the same exact proposition / Scope S / Consequence K and no governing precedence relation is constituted."
            ],
            "missing_information": [
              "No governing precedence relation exists for the exact concurrent authority conflict."
            ],
            "revision_status": "superseded"
          },
          "declared_reality": {
            "current_state_claims": [
              "R0 -> B1 -> C1 and R0 -> B2 -> C2 are prospectively frozen as current, attributable, internally valid, scope-sufficient and consequence-specific in both cases.",
              "C1 supports PERMIT and C2 supports REFUSE for the same proposition execution_authority_for_shared_execution, Scope scope-s and Consequence consequence-k.",
              "No precomputed winner, priority flag, override flag, selected authority, ordering-based answer or case-specific constitutional disposition is supplied to the Pack.",
              "Concurrent validity does not create precedence. Precedence must itself be constituted.",
              "Where no governing precedence relation exists, the Pack must not manufacture one from execution order or implementation convenience."
            ],
            "last_verified_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z"
          },
          "relational_rule": {
            "rule_id": "authority-disposition-rule-r2",
            "version": "1",
            "constituted_at": "T0",
            "scope": [
              "federated_shared_consequence"
            ],
            "expression": "A governing authority disposition for exact proposition P / Scope S / Consequence K may be constituted only after ordinary authority standing and any applicable precedence relation are resolved.",
            "source": "federation-constitution-r2"
          },
          "governing_basis": {
            "constituted_at": "T0",
            "domain_rule_ref": "authority-disposition-rule-r2@1",
            "root_trust_anchor_ref": "external-root-authority-register#R0-122-FROZEN",
            "precedence_rule_ref": null,
            "transition_vocabulary_contract": "Harmonic V3_8 state_transition relationship vocabulary",
            "case_specific_constitutional_answer_supplied": false
          },
          "authority_chain": {
            "subject": "federated-execution-agent",
            "issuer": "institutional-execution-authority",
            "scope": [
              "federated_shared_consequence",
              "scope-s",
              "consequence-k"
            ],
            "last_verified_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
            "chain": [
              {
                "actor": "federated-execution-agent",
                "status": "active"
              },
              {
                "actor": "institutional-execution-authority",
                "status": "active"
              }
            ]
          },
          "revocation_state": {
            "last_revocation_check_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
            "known_revocations": []
          },
          "obligation_witness": {
            "detected": true,
            "status": "not_applicable",
            "source": "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation",
            "evidence_refs": [
              "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation"
            ]
          },
          "consequence_profile": {
            "level": "low",
            "reversibility": "reversible",
            "execution_surface": "shared_execution",
            "blast_radius": "local"
          },
          "safeguards": {
            "operator_review_confirmed": true
          },
          "packet_id": "V122-AUTHORITY-PRECEDENCE-B-001",
          "observed_reality": {
            "signals": [
              {
                "statement": "Both represented authority paths remain current and scope-sufficient for the exact consequence.",
                "source": "federation-domain-pack",
                "evidence_ref": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122#concurrent-authority"
              },
              {
                "statement": "No governing precedence relation is present for the represented concurrent authority conflict.",
                "source": "federation-domain-pack",
                "evidence_ref": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122#precedence-absence"
              }
            ]
          },
          "present_state_provenance": {
            "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
            "established_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
            "epistemic_status": "UNRESOLVED",
            "evidence_refs": [
              "external-root-authority-register#R0-122-FROZEN",
              "external-root-authority-register#R0-B1-122-ACTIVE",
              "external-root-authority-register#R0-B2-122-ACTIVE",
              "institutional-delegation-registry#DELEG-B1-C1-122-001",
              "institutional-delegation-registry#DELEG-B2-C2-122-001",
              "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
              "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001",
              "authority-disposition-rule-r2@1",
              "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122"
            ]
          },
          "state_transition": {
            "prior_state_ref": "V122-T0-SINGLE-GOVERNING-AUTHORITY-ASSUMPTION",
            "new_observation_refs": [
              "institutional-authority-registry-c1#AUTH-C1-122-001",
              "institutional-authority-registry-c2#AUTH-C2-122-001"
            ],
            "relationship": "invalidates_prior_state",
            "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
            "observed_at": "2026-10-06T18:05:00.000Z",
            "scope": [
              "federated_shared_consequence",
              "scope-s",
              "consequence-k"
            ]
          },
          "specialty_pack_evidence": {
            "specialty_pack": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
            "proposition_id": "execution_authority_for_shared_execution",
            "exact_scope_id": "scope-s",
            "exact_consequence_id": "consequence-k",
            "root_anchor_id": "R0",
            "root_anchor_outside_falsifier": true,
            "concurrent_authority_paths": [
              {
                "path_id": "PATH-C1",
                "authority_class": "constitutional-control",
                "authority_id": "authority-node-c1",
                "disposition": "PERMIT",
                "valid": true,
                "delegation_id": "DELEG-B1-C1-122-001",
                "authority_instrument_id": "AUTH-C1-122-001"
              },
              {
                "path_id": "PATH-C2",
                "authority_class": "local-control",
                "authority_id": "authority-node-c2",
                "disposition": "REFUSE",
                "valid": true,
                "delegation_id": "DELEG-B2-C2-122-001",
                "authority_instrument_id": "AUTH-C2-122-001"
              }
            ],
            "concurrent_paths_valid": true,
            "concurrent_conflict_present": true,
            "candidate_dispositions": [
              "PERMIT",
              "REFUSE"
            ],
            "constitutional_answer_supplied": false,
            "precedence_relation_status": "ABSENT_FOR_CONFLICT",
            "precedence_rule_id": null,
            "constitution_status": "UNRESOLVED_AUTHORITY_CONFLICT",
            "proposition_value": null,
            "governing_authority_id": null,
            "governing_path_id": null,
            "relationship": "invalidates_prior_state",
            "relationship_basis": "both authority paths are current, valid, scope-sufficient and consequence-specific, but no constituted precedence relation governs their conflicting dispositions; no winner may be manufactured"
          }
        }
      },
      "fixture_evidence": {
        "reality_supplied": false,
        "reality_source": "exact_packet_replay",
        "declared_claim_count": 0,
        "observed_signal_count": 0,
        "consequence_profile_supplied": false,
        "consequence_profile_source": "exact_packet_replay"
      },
      "model_response_binding": {
        "role": "exact_packet_replay",
        "used_as_observed_reality": false,
        "response_supplied": false
      },
      "synthetic_fixture": {
        "translated": false,
        "source": null,
        "fields": []
      },
      "requested_action": {
        "present_in_packet": true,
        "caller_supplied": true,
        "provenance": "exact_packet_replay",
        "type": "shared_execution",
        "scope": [
          "federated_shared_consequence",
          "scope-s",
          "consequence-k"
        ]
      },
      "authority_provenance": {
        "supplied": false,
        "source": "not_supplied",
        "authority_history_event_count": 0,
        "original_authority_supplied": false,
        "authority_change_supplied": false,
        "current_authority_supplied": false
      },
      "obligation": {
        "supplied": true,
        "kind": null,
        "status": "not_applicable",
        "waiver_or_exception_active": null,
        "source": "v122-examination:no-separate-obligation"
      },
      "state_provenance": {
        "supplied": true,
        "source": "exact_packet_replay",
        "attributable_source": "federation-domain-pack@1.5.0-v122",
        "epistemic_status": "UNRESOLVED",
        "fixture_epistemic_status": null,
        "evidence_ref_count": 9
      },
      "downstream_accountability": {
        "supplied": false,
        "enforcement_layer_supplied": false,
        "next_decision_owner_supplied": false,
        "consequence_owner_supplied": false
      },
      "continuity": {
        "life_safety_context": null,
        "primary_authority_available": null,
        "emergency_continuity_defined": null,
        "explicit_emergency_activation": null,
        "emergency_authority_available": null,
        "emergency_authority": null
      },
      "mode": "exact_packet_replay",
      "exact_packet_replay": true,
      "semantic_translation_performed": false,
      "llm_involved_in_packet_construction": false,
      "outbound_sha256": "c0c32e9aef9281e06c3c2d86b554ac63765f187a912035132daadbeb59f8752b",
      "outbound_bytes": 7259,
      "transport_rule": "The operator-supplied JSON body was forwarded to /api/evaluate without semantic translation."
    }
  }
}