PERMITTED / ALLOW
consistent_with_prior_state → admissible true · Understanding Continuity UNDERSTANDING_CURRENT · revalidation required false.
V113 · Preserved successor examination
Complete information in. The answer stays out.
V113 prospectively examined whether Harmonic could discriminate a standing-preserving change from a standing-defeating change for the same consequential action when supplied the complete constituted information required by its interface — without receiving the case-specific constitutional answer upstream.
Frozen result
PASS — bounded to the governed-response boundary.
REFUSED / BLOCK
material_contradiction → admissible false · Understanding Continuity UNDERSTANDING_INADMISSIBLE · revalidation required true. Controlling signal: material_state_transition.
What was held constant
The change was authoritative reality — not the action or authority chain.
The frozen pair held the actor, authority, action, consequence, execution surface, governing basis, Specialty Pack, and Harmonic path constant. The Specialty Pack established the attributable domain relationship under the frozen domain rule. Harmonic received the complete constituted governing information required by its interface, but not a precomputed standing, revalidation, admissibility, ALLOW, or DENY answer.
Everything Harmonic legitimately needs goes in. The answer does not.
Claim boundary
What V113 establishes — and what it does not.
For the frozen implementation, interface, governing basis, Specialty Pack vocabulary, packets, and consequence surface, Harmonic discriminated the preserving and defeating changes at the governed-response boundary.
This result does not establish universal domain correctness, independent truth of supplied domain facts, arbitrary domain inference from raw observations, downstream physical execution or prevention, downstream executor compliance, or equivalence across successor implementations.
Preserved lineage
V109 and V112 were not rewritten.
V109 and V112 remain predecessor examinations. V113 corrected the examination constitution prospectively rather than retroactively repairing either record. Any material implementation or examination change after V113 is a successor and does not inherit this finding.
Download complete forensic packageOpen adjudicationOpen SHA-256 manifestPackage hash fileEarlier preserved lineageValidation protocol
Canonical forensic package SHA-256: 2650fa0d02e959d86a44494938076eb0d4f0f1ed6ce99e3e295a2707fae284cd
The complete preserved package is publicly downloadable from this page. Verify the downloaded ZIP against the canonical SHA-256 above before examination.